The Holly Park

CHASE, Circuit Judge.

At about six-forty p. m. on December 31,1926, the steam tug Frederick W. Underwood and the tramp steamer Holly Park were in collision in, the upper bay in the harbor of New York. Each sued the other, and the cases were heard together.

The Underwood, with a loaded car float made fast on either side, left Pier 21 East River at six o’clock p. m. that afternoon, bound for St. George, S. I. She was about one hundred twenty-five feet in length having her pilot house fifty feet from the stem. On her starboard was a wooden two-track float about one hundred fifty feet long loaded…