Metz v. Smith

On certiorari we review a discovery order in a law action. Petitioner was the defendant and respondent was the plaintiff below, and they will be referred to as such herein. Plaintiff sued for damages for personal injuries received in an automobile accident, alleging an authorized driver of defendant’s car negligently caused a collision. In a second count, a higher degree of negligence was alleged as a basis upon which to seek punitive damages. Defendant answered, admitting owning the car and lending it to the driver, but denying other allegations. Defendant averred the driver’s authorization…