Application of Philip v. Palmquist and James v. Erwin

SMITH, Judge.

Appellant has appealed from a decision of the Board of Appeals which affirmed the examiner’s rejection of all of the claims (claims 1-8) of appellants’ application Serial No. 434,323, filed June 3, 1954, entitled “Protective Reflective Film.” All the appealed claims were rejected on two grounds: (1) as unpatentable over the prior art and (2) on the ground of double patenting,

The references relied upon are:

Groten et al. 2,459,739 Jan. 18, 1949

Keithly 2,703,772 March 8, 1955 (Filed Sept. 12,1952)

Bosch (German) [720,980] Aprl. 16, 1942 (page 2, lines 3-27)

Clauser, “Metal Coated…