Shupe v. Pennsylvania Railroad

McILVAINE, District Judge.

Plaintiff filed a motion under Rule 34 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, *14528 U.S.C., seeking to obtain a copy his own statement given to a claim agent of the defendant apparently before plaintiff had counsel. Plaintiff also seeks to obtain copies of certain medical renorts made by a physician who examined plaintiff at defendant’s request. of

As to his own statement, under the decisions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit and which we are bound to follow, the test seems to be whether there are special circumstances which require the…