Office of the Lieutenant Governor v. Mohn

CONCURRING OPINION BY

Judge COHN JUBELIRER.

I agree that the Right to Know Law1 (RTKL) does not provide unconditional protection for home addresses. However, where, as here, the issue is raised, we must examine the Pennsylvania Constitution to determine whether the right to privacy affords protection in an individual case. The majority opinion states unequivocally that an individual can never assert a constitutional right to privacy in his or her home address under the Pennsylvania Constitution. Because I believe the majority opinion goes too far in making this declaration, I, respectfully,…