Hulen v. Stuart

KERRIGAN, J., Dissenting.

I dissent. The judgment in this case awards to the plaintiff, as the executrix of the estate of her deceased husband', William Y. Hulen, the sum of $2,000, being the amount of the agreed purchase price of twenty shares of the capital stock in a corporation, upon the mere breach on the part of the defendant of his agreement to purchase said stock, with nothing in the record to show either that title to the stock had passed to and vested in the defendant, or that the said sum of $2,000 was the difference between the contract price of the stock and the amount realized…