Coffee v. Ryan-Touhill

WEINZWEIG, Judge:

¶1 At issue here is whether parties may remove a trial judge under Arizona Rule of Civil Procedure ("Rule") 42.1(e) if they secure a new evidentiary hearing from the appellate court in a special action and they have not previously exercised their right to a change of judge.

¶2 This is the second of two consecutive petitions for special action in this matter. In the first, *668Coffee v. Ryan-Touhill ("Coffee I "), No. 1 CA-SA 18-0217, 2018 WL 5117110 (Ariz. App. Oct. 18, 2018), Joshua M. Coffee ("Father") moved for special action relief from the superior court's order that his…