BP America Production Company, Atlantic Richfield Company and Vastar Resources, Inc., (APPELLANTS/CROSS-APPELLEES) v. Vaquillas Ranch Co., Ltd., Vaquillas Unproven Minerals, Ltd., and Vaquillas Proven Minerals, Ltd., (APPELLEES/CROSS-APPELLANTS) Stanley G. Marshall, Jr., (APPELLEES ONLY)

• • • • • •

OPINION ON REHEARING

No. 04-06-00478-CV

BP AMERICA PRODUCTION COMPANY,

Atlantic Richfield Company, and Vastar Resources, Inc.,

Appellants

v.

Stanley G. MARSHALL Jr., Robert Ray Marshall, Catherine Irene Marshall

f/k/a Catherine I.M. Hashmi, and Margaret Ann Marshall f/k/a Margaret A.M. Jeffus,

by and through David Jeffus, as Independent Executor of the Estate of Margaret Marshall,

Appellees

&

VAQUILLAS RANCH CO., LTD., Vaquillas Unproven Minerals, Ltd.,

and Vaquillas Proven Minerals, Ltd.,

Appellants

v.

WAGNER OIL COMPANY f/k/a Duer Wagner & Co., Jacque Oil & Gas Limited,

Duer Wagner, Jr., Duer…