Buchanan v. Aetna Life Insurance

RYAN, Circuit Judge.

The plaintiff, Charles Buchanan, appeals the district court’s judgment in favor of the defendant, Aetna Life Insurance Company, on his ERISA claim for disability benefits, and on Aetna’s counterclaim for reimbursement of benefits it overpaid Buchanan. We AFFIRM the court’s judgment in favor of Aetna on Buchanan’s claim, but REVERSE the grant of summary judgment in favor of Aetna on its counterclaim.

I

Buchanan began working as a computer programmer for Progressive Casualty Insurance Company in September 1996 and was a participant under Progressive’s *306Managed Disability…