Northern Contracting Co. v. Allis-Chalmers Corp.

CAMERON, Chief Justice.

Plaintiff-Appellant, Northern Contracting Company, filed suit against defendantsappellees, Allis-Chalmers and Hugh T. Copien, in the Superior Court of Maricopa County alleging damages of $17,346.44 from the sale of faulty butterfly valves to Northern for use in a water main project for the City of Phoenix. Upon motion of the defendants, the trial court entered summary judgment for the defendants and plaintiff appealed. We took jurisdiction pursuant to Rule 47(e)(5), 17A A.R.S., Rules of the Supreme Court.

We must answer only one question on appeal: whether the evidence…