Anderson v. St. Francis-St. George Hospital, Inc.

We are presented with the following question: Where a medical provider administers a life-prolonging treatment or procedure to a patient against the patient’s instructions, is the medical provider liable for all foreseeable consequential damages resulting from the treatment or procedure? This is a case of first impression, and presents this court with the issues raised by a claim of “wrongful living.” In its simplest form, the question becomes: Is “continued living” a compensable injury?

American jurisprudence has developed at least three civil actions relating to the beginning and the…