ST. PAUL INS. CO. OF ILLINOIS v. Estate of Venute

Plaintiff, St. Paul Insurance Company of Illinois (St. Paul), and defendant and counterplaintiff, P.D.C. Facilities, Inc. (P.D.C.), filed separate appeals from a trial court order which dismissed the counts in St. Paul’s multicount complaint against defendants, the estate of Robert Venute, Jr., d/b/a Bob Venute Plumbing (Venute), and Walton Services Inc. (Walton), and also dismissed all counterclaims by codefendants. We consolidated the appeals.

St. Paul, as subrogee of the Greenberg Radiology Institute (Green-berg), filed a fourth amended complaint (complaint) containing seven counts. Counts…