Shefner v. Illinois Farmers Insurance

Plaintiffs, Sarah Shefner and Mark Brodie, appeal from a judgment declaring Sarah Shefner’s rights to uninsured motorist coverage under two automobile insurance policies issued by defendant, Illinois Farmers Insurance Company. The trial court held that Shefner was entitled to coverage under the policy issued for the car in which she was riding at the time of her collision with a vehicle driven by an uninsured motorist, but that she was not entitled to coverage under a second policy insuring another car plaintiffs own. On appeal, plaintiffs argue that Shefner is entitled to collect under the…