TGIP, Inc. v. AT & T Corp.

ORDER ON DEFENDANT’S MOTIONS FOR JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW,

RON CLARK, District Judge.

Plaintiff, TGIP Inc., claimed infringement of two patents relating to prepaid calling cards. The jury returned a verdict that was adverse in all respects to Defendant, AT & T Corporation, which timely made and renewed motions for judgment as a matter of law (“JMOL”) on alternative grounds. [Docs. # 469, # 472, # 478, # 479, & # 512], AT & T’s three arguments for JMOL on the issue of nonin-fringement are summarized as follows:

a. The claims teach that the call authorization amount of a card or account is not…