Berner v. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission

*29Dissenting Opinion by

Rhodes, P. J.:

I dissent from the majority opinion which affirms the order of the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission in this contested rate case. The record should be returned to the Commission for complete review, and especially that the Commission may make adequate findings supported by evidence on at least two matters: (1) Transactions between the utility and affiliates; and (2) rate of return. To comprehend these questions it is important to review the basic facts relating to this appeal by ratepayers.

The appeal is from the final order of the Commission dismissing…