Hoyt v. Tilton

At the outset of the case a question is presented as to the effect of the verdict which has been found for the defendant. It is urged on his behalf that the rule as to a general verdict and judgment should apply, and that therefore the verdict is conclusive against the plaintiff as to all facts which were in any way involved in the case as submitted to the jury.

The verdict establishes that no combination of facts existed which would warrant a recovery under the charge. That is, it is to be taken as true that the defendant did not furnish liquor whereby one not his servant became intoxicated…