Application of Julian Robert Anthony Beale

RICH, Judge.

This appeal is from the decision of the Patent Office Board of Appeals affirming the rejection of claims 52-54 of application serial No. 676,563, filed August 6, 1957, originally entitled “Method of Manufacturing Semi-Conductor Devices.”

Appellant Beale copied the three appealed claims from Schwartz et al. patent (hereinafter “Schwartz”) No. 3,001,895 1 to provoke an interference. They stand rejected on the sole ground of lack of support in Beale’s specification. The examiner’s language was that the claims are “unwarranted by the disclosure.”

*971The single issue in this case presents a…