City of Carmel v. Certain Southwest Clay Township Annexation Territory Landowners

SHEPARD, Chief Justice.

The City of Carmel annexed territory in the southwest corner of Hamilton County representing roughly 3,400 parcels, and re-monstrators contested the annexation. The organization leading the remonstrance negotiated favorable terms with the city and decided to settle. In a referendum among landowners, a majority voted in favor of settling. We conclude they were entitled to do so, and reverse the trial court’s judgment which effectively held otherwise.

Facts and Procedural History

At Carmel’s June 21, 2004 city council meeting, Carmel introduced ordinance C263 and a…