Borab Bros. v. United States

DISSENTING OPINION

Tilson, Judge:

Because of my strong conviction that my associates have fallen into error in both their reasoning and conclusion in this *21case, I feel compelled to dissent therefrom. In view of the fairness with which the majority have detailed the testimony, no good purpose would be served by a reiteration of the same by me. I shall therefore refer only to such portions of the testimony as I feel require special emphasis.

As I understand the record, the method of producing the material of which the imported merchandise was made was in substance that a certain number of rather…