The Catts Company, an Oklahoma Corporation v. Gulf Insurance Company, a Foreign Insurance Corporation

This is a case in which the trial court granted a directed verdict. If there were any issues of fact, that verdict cannot stand. The issues are only two: (1) whether the policy of insurance covers the kind of interest the plaintiff had in the steel at issue; and (2)'whether there was evidence from which the jury could have concluded that the company waived the requirement for monthly listing of inventories. Since I read the law and facts as requiring affirmative answers to both questions, I must respectfully dissent.

Coverage — The district court held that the policy did not cover the steel at…