Legal Opinion · Dissent

Smith v. Mitchell

West Virginia Supreme Court

Decided June 16, 1911Published

Petition by Homer Smith ancl others for mandamus to E. B. Mitchell, Clerk of the County Court of Mason County.

1DissentPoREENBERGER, Judge

Deeming this decision and the opinion upon which it stands palpably unsound, and wholly unsustained by any real authority, I dissent, and would grant peremptory writs of mandamus in all of the nine cases, commanding the clerk of the county court to issue the certificates of license.

The question for this Court is not one of license or no license. It is merely one of constitutional law, and nothing here involved calls for deviation from the plain letter of the constitution or the settled construction thereof. The doctrine of the opinion has never been adopted by the legislature of this state or…

2Cases cited21 opinions

  1. Gibson v. ChouteauSupreme Court of the United States · 1872
  2. Allopathic State Board of Medical Examiners v. FowlerSupreme Court of Louisiana · 1898
  3. May v. ToppingWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1909
  4. Capito v. ToppingWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1909
  5. Cleland v. AndersonNebraska Supreme Court · 1902

16 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API