Ogden v. Rowley

The appellant was the plaintiff below; his complaint contained two paragraphs. The first was based *57upon an award; the second was for one-half the cost or value of a partition-wall.

The defendant answered the first paragraph of the complaint in fifteen paragraphs; each attacking the award, and setting up facts to impeach it, of mistake, misconduct, and fraud of two of the arbitrators, the plaintiff, and his attorneys: as to the second, he answered, setting up the award in bar.

A demurrer was sustained to a part, and overruled as to a part, of the paragraphs of the answer to the first paragraph…