Cornish Town v. Koller

HALL, Chief Justice:

This case is on appeal for a second time from the First Judicial District Court, Cache County, this court having previously reversed in part and affirmed in part. 1 On remand, the trial court amended the findings of fact entered from the trial. Appellants objected and subsequently brought this appeal, claiming prejudicial error.

This is a long-standing dispute between the municipality of Cornish Town (Cornish) and Evan 0. and Marlene B. Roller (Rollers) over water rights. Rollers claimed that by deed from their predecessor in interest they are entitled to water rights…