Manhattan Chamber of Commerce v. Gallagher

*156The opinion of the court was delivered by

Mason, J.:

The Manhattan Chamber of Commerce sued Clifford Gallagher upon five causes of action, each based upon a note signed by him. Upon the first four a demurrer to the evidence was sustained, final judgment being rendered in favor of the defendant. Upon the fifth judgment was directed for the plaintiff. Both parties appeal.

Of the four notes on which no recovery was allowed one was made payable to F. C. Frank, as chairman of a student loan fund, and the other three to F. W. Jenson, as acting chairman of such fund. None of them was indorsed and there…