Trencor, Inc., Petitioner-Cross-Respondent v. National Labor Relations Board, Respondent-Cross-Petitioner

While I concur with the majority’s treatment of the union’s guarantees and its alleged “Cateh-22” campaign tactics, I cannot concur with its treatment of the alleged promise of a party and therefore respectfully dissent from its refusal to grant the Board’s petition for enforcement. My disagreement extends to several points, as I explain below.

In his report on Treneor’s objections to the election, the Regional Director for Region 16 stated as follows with respect to the issue of the party:

In support of this objection the Employer provided an employee witness who testified that a Union…