Grand Union Supermarkets of the Virgin Islands, Inc. v. Lockhart Realty Inc.

*249OPINION

CHAGARES, Circuit Judge.

Lockhart Realty Inc., formerly H.E. Lockhart Management, (“Lockhart”) appeals from the District Court’s judgment in favor of, and award of prejudgment interest and attorneys’ fees to, the plaintiff, Grand Union Supermarkets of the Virgin Islands, Inc. (“Grand Union”).1 For the reasons discussed below, we will reverse.

I

Because we write solely for the parties, we recount only the facts that are relevant to our disposition. This case, and three related cases involving the same parties, arose out of the destruction of a commercial structure in St. Thomas owned by…