Korein v. Conciliation & Appeals Board

Murphy, P. J., and Kupferman, J.,

dissent in a memorandum by Murphy, P. J., as follows: Upon the base date of May 31, 1968 (Code of the Real Estate Industry Stabilization Assn, of N. Y. City, Inc. [Code], § 2, subd [m]; § 62), this rent-stabilized building had elevator operators on a seven-day, 24-hour basis. In 1973, the owner discontinued that service without consulting the tenants or making an application to the Conciliation and Appeals Board (CAB). In opinion No. 2407, dated July 5, 1973, the CAB found that the manned elevator service was a “required service” (Code, § 2, subd [m]) and it…