Alford v. Northeast Insurance

MEMORANDUM DECISION

ARNOW, Senior District Judge.

Before the court is defendant’s amended motion for order compelling physical examination or the production of fingerprints (doc. 51). Plaintiff has responded and opposes such motion (doc. 52). Plaintiff contends the motion should be denied because his fingerprints are not relevant to the case, because the requested discovery is not of the sort contemplated by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and because the requested compulsion “would be invasive of the plaintiff’s constitutional rights.”

The plaintiff’s fingerprints are relevant to this…