Carroll v. Beard-Laney, Inc.

Mr. Associate Justice StukES

delivered the majority Opinion of the Court.

I respectfully dissent from the opinion of the ChiEE Justice for I think the case was properly submitted to the jury and this Court' should not undertake to decide it on the facts. And I do not think that the proposed decision to the contrary is required by the authority of the cited cases from this Court.

Knight v. Laurens Motor Car Co., 108 S. C., 179, 93 S. E., 869, L. R. A., 1918-B, 151, involved facts quite different. There an employee of an automobile garage took a car ouafter business hours (he had the keys) and…