Witt v. American Family Mutual Insurance

In these consolidated appeals, defendant American Family Mutual Insurance Company appeals by leave granted from an order setting aside an earlier decision to grant summary disposition in its favor, and from an order denying a second motion for summary disposition. Defendant Allstate Insurance Company also appeals by leave granted from an order denying its motion for summary disposition. We reverse.

This case arises out of a three-car accident that occurred on July 12, 1992. Plaintiff Mark W. Witt was driving his girlfriend’s car, and his girlfriend was following him in plaintiff’s vehicle. An…