Georgia Casualty & Surety Company, a Corporation v. Universal Underwriters Insurance Company, a Corporation

I agree with the majority that the risks and parties were covered by the policies and that the “other insurance” clauses were operative. However, I dissent from the majority’s holding that in this purely interinsurer dispute the identical provision in the two policies construed here does not “provide for” contribution by equal shares because I believe that holding to be at odds with the realities of insurance policywriting, the historical development of insurance law, and the intent of the parties to the insurance contracts in this case.

It must be remembered that policy provisions like those…