Keil v. Himes

WELSH, District Judge.

On January 3, 1952, plaintiff was examined by Dr. Arnold S. Levine on behalf of the defendant, Leonard H. Himes. On June 18, 1952, this action was brought by the plaintiff. On October 3, 1952, plaintiff was examined by Dr. John F. Gordon on behalf of the defendant, Leonard H. Himes.

Plaintiff has moved for the production of copies of the medical reports of the examining physicians. Defendant refuses to deliver them because one examination was conducted prior to the commencement of the action and because the other was submitted to by the plaintiff voluntarily. In other…