McKinnie Bros. v. Wester

The court instructed the jury as follows: “If you believe all the evidence you will answer the second issue 'No.’ ”

On 25 November, 1919, plaintiff and defendant exchanged wagons, defendant agreeing to pay “boot money.” There was a controversy between the parties, at the trial, as to the amount to be paid, but the jury has found that defendant agreed to pay $105, as contended by plaintiffs. Defendant testified and contended that the jury should find, from the evidence, that he paid the “boot money,” the next day after the trade, in accordance with the agreement, but the jury has found that…