Broadhurst v. Moenning

SHARPNACK, Chief Judge.

James G. Broadhurst appeals the trial court's entry of summary judgment in favor of Gainer Bank, N.A. ("the Bank") and Walter P. Moenning. We affirm in part and reverse in part.

Broadhurst presents the following restated and renumbered issues for our review:

1. whether Ind.Trial Rule 13(A), which provides for compulsory counterclaims, violates Article I, § 20 of the Indiana Constitution as applied in this case;

2. whether the logical relationship test for determining if a claim is a compulso ry counterclaim under T.R. 18(A) is inadequate;

8. whether the trial court erred in…