Silver v. McDonald

Plaintiffs, judgment creditors of defendant, garnisheed an elevator company at Shelly, Minnesota, and the Farmers State Bank of Shelly intervened, claiming the grain held by the garnishee. The court made findings in favor of the intervener. Plaintiffs appeal from the order denying their motion for a new trial.

The grain was raised by defendant on his farm in Traill county, North Dakota. His market town was Shelly, Minnesota. Intervener held a chattel mortgage, dnly filed for record in Traill county as prescribed by the laws of North Dakota, when the plaintiffs served the garnishee summons. The…