Paine v. Foster

Dissenting opinion by

McAtee, J.:

While differing from the majority of the ' court in my views of the law which direct the final determination of this case, I yet agree with an exception *260with my associates upon the legal propositions laid down in eight of the ten heads comprising the syllabus of the opinion which has been adopted, in part, as the opinion •of this court. The exception referred to is upon the proposition, that conclusions and inferences from facts, made by the secretary of the interior, are final and binding upon courts. The question of parties as treated in the original opinion…