Trinidad Creamery Co. v. McDonald

McDonald, plaintiff below, had a verdict and judgment against the plaintiff in error, defendant below, for one dollar, in an action for converting and adulterating plaintiff’s cream, and the defendant brings error. The defendant set up a counterclaim which charged plaintiff with the same conduct with which he charged defendant. The verdict on the counterclaim was for plaintiff.

The complaint alleged and the evidence showed that the plaintiff and defendant were competing in Trinidad in the purchase of cream and in the manufacture and sale of products therefrom, and that they purchased the cream…