Apex Oil Co. v. DiMauro

OPINION

WALKER, District Judge:

INDEX TO THE OPINION

I. PROCEDURAL HISTORY.!'”7T.....591

II. FACTS.592

III. BELCHER’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

A. Introduction.593

B. Standard for Summary Judgment.594

C. Claims under § 1 of the Sherman Act.594

1. Count One.596

2. Counts Two and Three.597

D. Claim under § 2 of the Sherman Act (count four).599

E. Claim under the Commodities Exchange Act (Count 5).601

F. Conclusion as to Belcher’s Summary Judgment Motion.603

IV. APEX’S MOTION TO STRIKE BELCHER’S AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES.603

V. APEX’S MOTION TO DISMISS BELCHER’S COUNTERCLAIMS

A. Introduction.605

B. Inequitable…