Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc. v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. Introduction. 1140

A. Background and Procedure. 11.40

B. The Insurance Policies. 1141

1. Aetna’s Comprehensive General Liability Policies. 1141

2. LMI’s Excess and Umbrella Policies . 1142

C. Standard for Summary Judgment. 1143

II. The Expected/Intended Clause. 1143

A. Legal Issues. 1143

1. Burden of Proof .. 1143

2. Objective or Subjective Intent. 1145

B. Aetna’s Motion for Summary Judgment on Its Pre-1961 “Accident”-

Based Policies. 1147

C. The Parties’ Cross-Motions for Summary Judgment on the Expected/Intended Issue.'. 1148

1. Chemical Leaman’s Evidence. 1149

2. Defendants’…