Legal Opinion

Seeley v. Birdsall

New York Supreme Court

Decided May 15, 1818PublishedCited by 9 opinions

THIS was an action on the case against the defendant, late sheriff of the county of Seneca, for a false return on a writ of fieri facias issued out of this court, at the suit of the plaintiff against W. I. Seeley. The cause was tried before Mr. J. Spencer, at the circuit in Cayuga county, where the venue was laid, in June, 1817. The plaintiff recovered a judgment against W, I. Seeley for 3,988 dollars of debt, and 14 dollars and 4'3 cents damages and costs.

Read the full summary

THIS was an action on the case against the defendant, late sheriff of the county of Seneca, for a false return on a writ of fieri facias issued out of this court, at the suit of the plaintiff against W. I. Seeley. The cause was tried before Mr. J. Spencer, at the circuit in Cayuga county, where the venue was laid, in June, 1817. The plaintiff recovered a judgment against W, I. Seeley for 3,988 dollars of debt, and 14 dollars and 4'3 cents damages and costs. A fieri facias was issued thereon, to which the defendant returned, that he had sold all the goods and chattels of W. J. Seeley to be…

1Per curiam

An action on the case against a sheriff for a false return on an execution, is within the first section of the statute, (1 JV L. 155.) “ for the more easy pleading in certain suits and, consequently, the burthen of the proof, that the cause of action arose within the county wherein the venue is laid, is thrown on the plaintiff, and the failure to give that proof entitled the defendant to a verdict of not guilty.

The words of the statute are very plain and perspicuous. If any action upon the case be brought against any sheriff, &c. for or concerning any matter or thing by him doni, by virtue of…

2Cited by9 opinions

  1. Gerber v. AckleyWisconsin Supreme Court · 1875
  2. Burns v. ClarkCalifornia Supreme Court · 1901
  3. Dennison v. PlumbNew York Supreme Court · 1854
  4. Bishop v. McGillisWisconsin Supreme Court · 1891
  5. Berry v. SchaadNew York Supreme Court · 1899

4 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API