Giles v. Welsh

Both of the above entitled actions arose out of a collision between an automobile owned by plaintiff Giles and a truck owned by defendant Sargent Auto Company, operated by Justin Welsh. At the time of the accident, plaintiffs Giles and Amos were in the former’s car, with the latter driving. Each plaintiff had judgment, and defendants have appealed. Both actions were tried at the same time, on the same evidence, before the court without a jury, and each presents the same questions for determination.

The evidence is sharply conflicting as to some of the facts. The findings of the trial court in…