Legal Opinion · Dissent

State Ex Rel. Foster v. Naftalin

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided January 20, 1956No. 36,749Published

1DissentThomas Gallagher, Justice

I am of the opinion that our decisions in Bull v. King, supra, and Freeman v. Goff, supra, should be overruled as against the trend of modern authority and that we should adopt what has been designated as the “rule of severability.” Thereunder, an enactment of the legislature, some minor section of which contains a material variation from that signed by the Governor, would not be held invalid as to those sections to which the variance had no relation, and which therefore could be fully executed on the basis of the specific language thereof. Under this rule, if applied in the instant case, L.…

2Cases cited12 opinions

  1. Berry v. Baltimore & Drum Point RailroadCourt of Appeals of Maryland · 1875
  2. State ex rel. Casper v. MooreNebraska Supreme Court · 1893
  3. Gwynn v. HardeeSupreme Court of Florida · 1926
  4. People ex rel. Brady v. LaSalle Street Trust & Savings BankIllinois Supreme Court · 1915
  5. State Ex Rel. Board of Commissioners v. WrightWyoming Supreme Court · 1945

7 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API