Pvm Redwood Company, Inc. v. United States

I respectfully dissent. I would reverse the order dismissing the complaint and direct the district court to permit PVM to attempt to amend the pleading to state its claim in a clear and concise manner. I believe that PVM has set forth facts which establish that its property has been taken by the government.

I am in complete agreement with my colleagues’ fine analysis and rejection of PVM’s statutory claim for relief. I do not agree with the majority’s interpretation of PVM’s constitutional claim.

*1330I.

THE STATUTORY CLAIM

PVM argues that since the Expansion • Act provides for employees, whose…