Butcher v. Scott Ex Rel. J.L.R.

This case concerns the liability of a beneficial owner of real property for the criminal acts of a co-owner. We reverse the judgment of the court of appeals, 906 S.W.2d 16.

J.L.R., a minor under the age of ten, was sexually abused by Robert Butcher, the brother of Randy Butcher, at a house that had been bequeathed to the Butchers by their father. Randy Butcher’s interest was held in trust by Danny Butcher until Randy reached the age of 25, and Randy was the beneficial owner of an undivided half interest in the house at the time of the abuse.

Patricia Ann Scott, J.L.R.’s grandmother, sued Robert…