Northshore School District No. 417 v. Kinnear

(dissenting) — This case encompasses the most important combination of constitutional, taxation and educational issues faced by the Supreme Court in its recent *732history. The decision has had a long, difficult, stormy, and ofttimes painful, period of gestation. Unfortunatély, in the end, the opinion characterized as the majority has given birth to a legal pygmy of doubtful origin.

The result may give temporary solace to some because it will be easy to live with on a temporary basis. But, the majority opinion cannot withstand a critical analysis either factually or legally. Thus, resting as it…