Peter S. Karlow v. William Fitzgerald

MAGRUDER, Circuit Judge.

Plaintiff and defendant were neighbors. Defendant’s bulldog, named Bow ser, went onto plaintiff’s premises without the plaintiff’s having shown any prior manifestation of consent to such entry. Plaintiff testified on his direct examination that when the defendant’s dog came upon his premises it first attacked him by biting him on the arm, and then jumped on his dog. From other testimony it may perhaps be inferred that plaintiff suffered the injury complained of as a result of an attempt to separate the fighting dogs. It is difficult to say from the record that this…