State Ex Rel. O'Connell v. Meyers

(dissenting) — The thesis of this dissent is based on three tenets:

*470First: Laws of 1957, chapter 5, p. 11 (hereafter referred to as initiative No. 199), is constitutional; (section D, infra)

Second: Laws of 1957, chapter 289, p. 1147, is an unconstitutional repeal of initiative No. 199; (section E, infra)

Third: Laws of 1957, chapter 289, is unconstitutional regardless of any relation it may have to initiative No. 199. (section F, infra).

A. Ultimate Question

The ultimate question is whether senatorial and representative districts established by initiative No. 199, or senatorial and representative…