Legal Opinion · Concurrence

Chavez v. Chavez

New Mexico Supreme Court

Decided October 9, 1935No. 4023Published

1ConcurrenceBickley, Justice

Recrimination is not a defense of substantive law. There is no mention of it in our statutes. It arises as a matter of procedure in courts of equity and is based on the “clean hands” maxim

This maxim is not of universal application even m cases entirely distinct from divorce proceedings. In 21 C. J., “Equity,” § 176, the “conduct of adversary” is considered as a limitation on the maxim. It is there said: “The conduct of the other party may be sufficient to prevent the maxim from being applied, as where plaintiff’s misconduct toward defendant was invited by him, or waived. The courts incline to…

2Cases cited7 opinions

  1. Decker v. DeckerIllinois Supreme Court · 1901
  2. Green v. GreenCourt of Appeals of Maryland · 1915
  3. Redington v. RedingtonColorado Court of Appeals · 1892
  4. Hodges v. HodgesNew Mexico Supreme Court · 1916
  5. Ex Parte SedilloNew Mexico Supreme Court · 1929

2 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API