Coltec Industries, Inc. v. American Motorists Insurance

MEMORANDUM ORDER

BOBRICK, United States Magistrate Judge.

Before the court is the motion of plaintiff Coltec Industries, Inc. (“Coltec”) to compel production of documents from defendant Zurich Insurance Company (“Zurich”).

The instant case concerns Zurich’s coverage obligations under insurance policies it issued Coltec between thirty-five and forty-one years ago. The parties have struggled with the instant discovery dispute to a degree that would not seem possible. It would appear that, at last count, 47 documents are presently at issue which Zurich has claimed are protected from discovery under…