H. B. Claflin Co. v. Knapp

Patterson, J.:

From an order denying a motion made by the plaintiff for a bill of particulars an appeal is taken. That the motion was properly denied as to most of the matter in respect of which information was sought, is plainj but in respect of one subject only we think it should have been granted. The defendant Jane Knapp is sued upon a guaranty executed by her and a co-defendant and delivered to the plaintiff. In her answer Jane Knapp sets ■' up as a separate defense that if the instrument mentioned in the complaint was executed by her, it was obtained by the plaintiff and others in…